-- Testing and Results
-- Page: 1
2
What we will be testing is a comparison between the
older version of the Gladiator and with other coolers we have come
across.
Note: We have since changed our temperature
measuring from using the onboard sensor on the motherboard, to using
the CompuNurse,
an external temperature probe. This probe is situated
right next to the CPU slug, so it provides the most precise
temperature reading as possible.
Our trusty old test rig is as follows:
-
IWill KK266 Socket A Motherboard
-
AMD Thunderbird 800Mhz CPU
-
Crucial PC133 CL2 Ram, 128MB
The test will consist of an idle
temperature check and a full load temperature check. The full
load will be accomplished by using the RC5
program and running 3DMark
2001 for 30 minutes. Arctic Silver thermal paste is used
as usual.
Here are some results:
|
Models |
AMD Tbird 800 Stock |
AMD Tbird 800 @ 1003
(1.85V) |
| Ambient
Temp. = 27C |
Idle |
Full
Load |
Idle |
Full
Load |
| OCZ
Gladiator |
35C |
37C |
41C |
45C |
| ThermalRight
SK-6 |
31C |
34C |
36C |
40C |
| GlobalWin
CAK38 |
34C |
37C |
38C |
42C |
| ThermalTake
Dragon Orb 3 |
35C |
37C |
38C |
43C |
| Vantec
CCK-6035D |
32.5C |
35.5C |
36C |
42C |
| >>
SVC Golden Gate 40 << |
33.5C |
36C |
39.5C |
43.5C |
We discussed the results with Rodney, the tech at SVC
and he did mention that the results may prove even better when using
a faster chip. Possibly showing off the GG's ability to
dissipate heat at higher temperatures. So I went out and
bought (ok...I borrowed, well...ok...if you call taking without
asking and returning without telling as borrowing, then yup, that's
what I did..anyway), the results are rather surprising. I used
an AXIA 1Ghz oc'd to a solid 1450Mhz. This unit does better
when a larger amount of heat is pumped through it.
|
Models |
AMD Tbird 1000@1450 |
| Ambient
Temp. = 27C |
Idle |
Full
Load |
| OCZ
Gladiator |
42C |
45C |
| ThermalRight
SK-6 |
38C |
41C |
| GlobalWin
CAK38 |
39C |
44C |
| ThermalTake
Dragon Orb 3 |
38C |
43.5C |
| Vantec
CCK-6035D |
36.5C |
43C |
| >>
SVC Golden Gate 40 << |
40C |
44C |
From our test, the cooler does better than the
older version across the board. But this is using the 40CFM fan. We did
take that fan off and used our standard 38CFM Delta, the scores came
in and the results were pretty much identical.
After taking the results from using the higher speed
chip, it is apparent that the unit (SVC's and the Gladiator) perform
better at higher speeds to some extent. I know the copper was doing its job,
I could feel the heat blown out of the heatsink by the fan.
So what does this mean? Users who have slower CPUs won't benefit
from this performance? Or is this cooler just aimed for the power
users? From what I see, both types of chips should benefit greatly
compared to the common heatsink.
So the changes in the heatsink and shroud design did
not alter anything too much. The higher speed fan did provide more air
and in return lower temperatures. What does set this unit
apart from the others is that, it only cost about $25 USD. This
includes the 40CFM fan, which I have seen from other retailers have
been going for about $10 extra to add on. So overall, this is
not a bad deal. From my experience with the folks at SVC,
their customer service is beyond remarkable. The tech that I
talked to was knowledgeable and courteous, something that will
definitely set them apart from the pack.

Pros:
- Strong Clip
- Copper based unit
- Strong fan!
- Very affordable
- Works nicely on higher speed CPUs
Cons:
- Still hard to push down on the clip
- Loud fan, if that kind of thing bothers you
|

|
|